Unveiling the Mystery of Myrtle's Death: Examining the Culprits in The Great Gatsby

Well folks, it's the question that has been plaguing literary enthusiasts for decades: Who Killed Myrtle in The Great Gatsby? Was it Daisy Buchanan, Tom Buchanan, or perhaps even Jay Gatsby himself? The mystery surrounding Myrtle's death is one of the most intriguing plot points in F. Scott Fitzgerald's classic novel, and has left readers scratching their heads for ages.

Now, before we dive into the nitty-gritty details of this case, let's take a moment to appreciate just how wild this story really is. We've got a wealthy socialite with a shady past, a cheating husband who can't seem to keep it in his pants, and a mysterious millionaire who throws extravagant parties every weekend. It's like a soap opera on steroids!

So, let's start at the beginning. Myrtle Wilson is introduced to us as the mistress of Tom Buchanan, a wealthy man who is married to the beautiful and enigmatic Daisy. Myrtle is described as being loud, brash, and desperate to climb the social ladder. She's not exactly the most likable character, but that doesn't mean she deserved to be run over by a car.

The night of Myrtle's death, she is hit by a car that is being driven by Daisy. Or is it? Some readers speculate that it was actually Gatsby behind the wheel, trying to protect Daisy from taking the fall. Others believe that it was Tom who was driving, trying to get revenge on Myrtle for her affair with him.

Speaking of Tom, he definitely had motive to kill Myrtle. Not only was he angry at her for refusing to stop calling him, but he was also furious that she had the audacity to mention Daisy's name during their argument. Tom has a violent streak, and it wouldn't be surprising if he took matters into his own hands.

But what about Daisy? She definitely had the means to kill Myrtle, as she was driving Gatsby's car that fateful night. Plus, Myrtle's death would have been convenient for Daisy, as it would have eliminated the threat of her husband's mistress once and for all.

Of course, there are those who believe that Gatsby was responsible for Myrtle's death. Maybe he was trying to protect Daisy, or maybe he was so consumed by his love for her that he didn't care about the consequences. Either way, it's a possibility worth considering.

So, who killed Myrtle in The Great Gatsby? The truth is, we may never know for sure. Fitzgerald leaves the answer up to interpretation, allowing readers to draw their own conclusions. But one thing is for certain: the mystery surrounding Myrtle's death is just one of the many reasons why The Great Gatsby continues to captivate audiences to this day.

The Great Mystery of Myrtle's Death

As I sat in my cozy armchair, sipping hot cocoa and reading The Great Gatsby for the umpteenth time, I couldn't help but wonder, who killed Myrtle? Was it Daisy, Tom, or someone else entirely? As a self-proclaimed amateur detective, I decided to dive deep into the novel and solve this great mystery once and for all. Hold on to your hats, folks, because this is going to be a wild ride.

The Suspects

Let's start with the obvious suspects: Daisy and Tom. They were both present at the scene of the crime, and they both had motive. Myrtle was having an affair with Tom, and Daisy was jealous. But could either of them really be capable of murder?

Daisy, with her delicate voice and fluttering eyelashes, seems like the last person who would commit such a heinous act. But as we know, appearances can be deceiving. She did hit and kill Myrtle with Gatsby's car, after all. Maybe she was so consumed by her jealousy that she lashed out and killed Myrtle in a fit of rage.

Tom, on the other hand, is a bit more rough around the edges. He's a big, burly man who isn't afraid to throw a punch when he's angry. But would he really go so far as to murder his mistress? It's possible, especially considering how much he seemed to despise Myrtle. But something about him just doesn't quite scream murderer.

The Other Players

Of course, there are plenty of other characters in The Great Gatsby who could have had a hand in Myrtle's death. Let's take a closer look at some of them.

First up, we have Gatsby himself. He was driving the car that hit Myrtle, after all. But would he really have intentionally killed someone? It seems unlikely. Gatsby was so fixated on Daisy that he probably wasn't even paying attention to the road. Plus, he seemed genuinely devastated by Myrtle's death.

Then there's Wilson, Myrtle's husband. He's an interesting character because he's almost too obvious a suspect. He's the one who actually pulls the trigger and kills Gatsby, so it wouldn't be a stretch to think that he also killed Myrtle. But again, something about him just doesn't quite fit. He's too meek, too desperate. It's hard to imagine him doing something so bold and violent.

The Real Culprit?

So if it wasn't any of these characters, who could it have been? Well, I have a theory. Are you ready for it?

The real culprit...was the green light.

Yes, you read that right. The green light. Hear me out.

Throughout the novel, the green light is a symbol of hope, of possibility. It represents everything that Gatsby longs for, everything that he's trying to achieve. But it's also a symbol of the past. No matter how hard Gatsby tries, he can never go back to the way things were with Daisy.

So where does Myrtle fit into all of this? Well, think about it. Myrtle was a symbol of the present. She was a real, living person who represented everything that Gatsby couldn't have. And when he accidentally killed her with his car, it was like he was destroying that part of his life. He was destroying the present.

Okay, I know this theory is a bit out there. But isn't that what makes literature so fascinating? We can interpret it in so many different ways, and there's always something new to discover.

The Verdict

In the end, we may never know for sure who killed Myrtle. Maybe it was Daisy, maybe it was Tom, maybe it was Wilson, or maybe it was the green light. But one thing is certain: The Great Gatsby is a masterpiece of literature that will continue to captivate readers for generations to come.

So pour yourself a drink (or a cup of hot cocoa, if you're like me), sit back, and enjoy the ride. Because when it comes to solving the mystery of Myrtle's death, sometimes it's more about the journey than the destination.

Who Killed Myrtle In The Great Gatsby?

The mystery surrounding Myrtle's death has puzzled readers for years. As a proud member of the literary community, I've put on my detective hat and attempted to solve this whodunit. Let's examine the suspects and their potential motives.

Well, It Wasn't Me! - Nick Attempts to Clear His Name

Nick claims he had nothing to do with Myrtle's death, and we'll take his word for it. He may be an unreliable narrator, but he doesn't strike me as a killer. Plus, he's too busy being the voice of reason in this mess.

A Clueless Car Crash - Daisy's Driving Skills (or Lack Thereof)

Daisy's driving skills are questionable, to say the least. Her reckless behavior behind the wheel makes her a prime suspect in Myrtle's death. However, I don't think she meant to hurt anyone. She was simply distracted by her emotions and poor decision-making skills.

Gatsby's Great Gaslighting - Was He Really at a Pool Party?

Gatsby claims he was at a pool party during the time of Myrtle's death, but can we trust him? He's a master manipulator and could have easily fabricated an alibi. However, I think he's innocent. He's too obsessed with Daisy to risk anything happening to her.

Jordan Baker's Suspicious Silence - Did She See Something and Say Nothing?

Jordan may have seen something on the night of Myrtle's death, but she's not talking. Her silence is suspicious, but it doesn't necessarily make her a murderer. Perhaps she's protecting someone she cares about, or maybe she just doesn't want to get involved.

Tom's Temper Tantrum - Could His Rage Have Turned Deadly?

Tom's temper is legendary, and he definitely had a motive to kill Myrtle. However, I don't think he did it. He's too self-involved to risk getting caught up in a murder investigation. Plus, his arrogance wouldn't allow him to take the blame for something like this.

Wilson's Wayward Shotgun - Did George Shoot More Than Just Gatsby?

George may have been seeking revenge for his wife's death and accidentally shot Gatsby instead of the intended target. However, I don't think he killed Myrtle. He was too grief-stricken to think clearly, and his actions were fueled by emotion rather than logic.

The Ghost of Myrtle's Lovers - Could She Have Had Other Enemies?

Myrtle was a mistress to many wealthy men, any of whom could have had a motive to kill her. However, there's no evidence to support this theory. It's purely speculation, and we can't accuse someone without proof.

A Murderous Mistaken Identity - Was Myrtle Meant to Be Someone Else's Target?

Perhaps Myrtle was mistaken for someone else, and the killer had the wrong person. This theory is possible, but it's unlikely. Myrtle was the only one on the street at the time, and it's doubtful someone would make such a critical mistake.

The Curious Case of the Missing Dog Leash - A Clue or a Red Herring?

The missing dog leash is a curious detail that could be a clue or a red herring. Perhaps the killer used it to strangle Myrtle, or maybe it's just a coincidence. We'll never know for sure.

The Unsolvable Mystery - Or, How Fitzgerald Fooled Us All.

Ultimately, we may never know who killed Myrtle. Fitzgerald intentionally left the ending open to interpretation, and it's up to us to fill in the blanks. But perhaps that's the beauty of the story - it keeps us guessing and discussing for years to come.

So, dear reader, who do you think killed Myrtle?

Who Killed Myrtle in The Great Gatsby?

The Story of Myrtle's Death

It was a dark and stormy night in West Egg, Long Island. Myrtle Wilson, the mistress of Tom Buchanan, was driving along the road towards her lover's mansion when she was struck and killed by a car. The driver didn't stop, and Myrtle was left to die on the side of the road.

The police were called, and soon the news spread that Myrtle had been killed. Everyone in West Egg seemed to have a theory about who was behind the hit-and-run. Was it Tom, who had been seen arguing with Myrtle earlier that day? Or perhaps it was Gatsby, who was known to frequent the area in his flashy car. Some even suspected Daisy, Tom's wife, who had been seen driving a similar car earlier that evening.

The Point of View on Who Killed Myrtle

Now, I know what you're thinking. Who really killed Myrtle? It's a mystery that has puzzled readers and fans of The Great Gatsby for years. But let me tell you, I have a theory that will blow your mind.

1. Tom Buchanan: Let's start with the obvious suspect. Tom and Myrtle had a tumultuous relationship, to say the least. They argued constantly, and Tom was known to be a violent man. It's possible that in a fit of rage, he hit Myrtle with his car and fled the scene. But would he really risk everything just to silence his mistress?
2. Gatsby: Some people believe that Gatsby was behind Myrtle's death. He was seen driving his flashy car near the scene of the crime, and he had a motive for wanting Myrtle out of the picture. But Gatsby was a man with a reputation to uphold. He wouldn't risk everything he had worked so hard for just to get rid of one woman.
3. Daisy Buchanan: Ah, Daisy. The ultimate femme fatale. Some believe that she was the one behind Myrtle's death. After all, she was seen driving a car similar to the one that hit Myrtle. But would Daisy really kill someone just to protect her own reputation?

The Real Culprit

So, who killed Myrtle? It wasn't Tom, Gatsby, or Daisy. No, my friends. The real culprit was none other than Jay Gatsby's gardener.

Yes, you heard me right. The man who tended to Gatsby's lawn was the one who killed Myrtle. But why, you ask? Well, it's simple. The gardener was in love with Myrtle. He had been watching her from afar for months, and when he saw her arguing with Tom on the side of the road, he knew he had to act.

He jumped into Gatsby's car and sped towards Myrtle, intending to scare her and Tom into ending their argument. But things went horribly wrong when Myrtle ran into the road and was struck by the car. The gardener panicked and fled the scene, leaving Myrtle to die.

Conclusion

And there you have it, folks. The mystery of Myrtle's death has finally been solved. It just goes to show you that sometimes, the most unlikely suspects are the ones who are guilty.

Closing Message: Who Killed Myrtle In The Great Gatsby?

Well, well, well. It looks like we've come to the end of our little investigation into the death of poor Myrtle Wilson in F. Scott Fitzgerald's classic novel, The Great Gatsby. We've explored all the possible suspects, analyzed all the clues, and even delved into some of the deeper themes of the book.

So, who killed Myrtle? Was it her husband, George? Or perhaps Tom Buchanan, the rich and powerful man she was having an affair with? Maybe it was even Gatsby himself, who was driving the car that hit her.

But let's be real here. Do we really care who killed Myrtle? I mean, sure, it's a central plot point in the book, but there's so much more to The Great Gatsby than just a murder mystery. There's the opulence and excess of the Roaring Twenties, the disillusionment of the American Dream, and the tragic love story between Gatsby and Daisy.

And yet, here we are, still fixated on poor Myrtle and her untimely demise. It's almost as if we're trying to distract ourselves from the bigger issues at play in the book. But hey, I get it. It's human nature to want to solve a puzzle, even if it's not the most important one.

So, let's indulge ourselves for just a moment longer. If we had to pick a culprit, who would it be? Well, there's certainly evidence to suggest that George had motive – after all, he did find out about his wife's affair and was seen lurking around Tom's house on the night of the accident.

On the other hand, Tom is clearly not a good guy. He's a racist, a misogynist, and an all-around jerk. It wouldn't be surprising if he had some blood on his hands (or bumper, as the case may be).

And then there's Gatsby. He's the titular character, the one we're supposed to root for, but he's also involved in some shady business dealings and has a tendency to be reckless behind the wheel. Could he have been the one who ended Myrtle's life?

In the end, it doesn't really matter. The point of The Great Gatsby is not to solve a murder mystery, but to explore the complexities of human relationships and the emptiness of material wealth. It's a cautionary tale about the dangers of chasing after an unattainable ideal, and the tragic consequences that can result.

So, my dear readers, let's put aside our fascination with Myrtle's death and focus instead on the bigger picture. Let's appreciate the beauty of Fitzgerald's prose, the intricacy of his characters, and the timeless relevance of his themes. And if we happen to solve the mystery along the way, well, that's just a bonus.

Thank you for joining me on this little journey through The Great Gatsby. I hope you've enjoyed it as much as I have. Who knows – maybe we'll meet again someday, to unravel another literary enigma or simply to revel in the joys of great literature. Until then, farewell!

Who Killed Myrtle In The Great Gatsby?

People Also Ask

1. Did Tom Buchanan kill Myrtle?

No, Tom Buchanan did not kill Myrtle. Although he was having an affair with her, he was in New York City at the time of her death.

2. Did Daisy Buchanan kill Myrtle?

Technically, yes. Daisy was driving Gatsby's car when she hit Myrtle, and although it was an accident, she was responsible for her death.

3. Why did George Wilson think Gatsby killed Myrtle?

George Wilson believed that Gatsby was driving the car that killed Myrtle because he found a pair of yellow glasses in Gatsby's car and assumed they belonged to the driver. However, the glasses actually belonged to Gatsby's business associate, and Gatsby himself was not driving the car at the time of the accident.

Answering People Also Ask Using Humorous Voice and Tone

Oh, the mystery of Myrtle's death in The Great Gatsby! It's a question that has puzzled readers for years. Let's take a closer look, shall we?

1. Did Tom Buchanan kill Myrtle?

Well, Tom certainly had motive - he was sleeping with Myrtle behind his wife's back. However, he was actually in New York City at the time of her death, so we can't pin this one on him.

2. Did Daisy Buchanan kill Myrtle?

Yes, technically Daisy was behind the wheel when Myrtle met her untimely demise. But let's not forget that she was also under the influence of alcohol and had just found out her husband was cheating on her. So, we can cut her a little slack.

3. Why did George Wilson think Gatsby killed Myrtle?

Ah, poor George. He was so distraught over his wife's death that he wanted someone to blame. Unfortunately, he jumped to the conclusion that Gatsby was responsible because of a pair of yellow glasses he found in the car. Of course, we all know that those glasses actually belonged to Gatsby's business associate. Classic case of mistaken identity!

So there you have it, folks. The true culprit behind Myrtle's demise in The Great Gatsby was...a tragic combination of circumstances and bad decisions. And maybe a little bit of fate thrown in for good measure. Who knows?